Poll - M Vs Jklaroe - Simply Maya User Community

View Poll Results: Who should win this battle?
Jklaroe	2	15.38%
M	11	84.62%
Voters: 13. You may not vote on this poll

Integrating 3D models with photography

Interested in integrating your 3D work with the real world? This might help

Watch

# 1 11-04-2003 , 11:06 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Jan 2003

Location: BC, Canada

Posts: 2,250

Poll - M Vs Jklaroe

Hey, just letting you know that this is a poll for the challenge against I and Jklaroe.. the reason for this is stated in the rules. Mods usually vote winner, but because its a mod in a competition, you decide user added image

. You can only vote once, make it wise user added image

"I should call you sugar maple tree cause i'd totally tap that" haha

email - mattwettstein@gmail.com

Quote

# 2 11-04-2003 , 11:36 PM

Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2002

Location: CCS, Venezuela

Posts: 3,363

-Voted-

adldesigner
Caracas, Venezuela
Hell .. not gone perse, but with a certainly lower post count per day.

Quote

# 3 11-04-2003 , 11:56 PM

Simply Maya OG
Join Date: Dec 2002

Location: Queensbury NY, US A

Posts: 1,438

Voted for M. Main reason is that M's gun looks more like the actual model. A few things about Jklaroe's gun:

1) the handle area; its too blocky. needs some more roundness. have you ever held something square like that? it aint too comfortable. 2)The magizine area isnt defined too well. You cant really tell where the magazine and the slot for it seperate. 3) The barrel of it is solid. How would the bullets come out the barrel if its blocked up solid?

A few things about M's gun:
1)Blocky edges. I think that you could of made your gun more sleek, more smoother. 2)The overall design of the gun is more complicated, therefor making more of a challenge.

Ok, theres my reasons user added image

Nice job both you you!

- Hybrid

Quote

# 4 12-04-2003 , 04:35 AM

Subscriber
Join Date: Jan 2003

Location: BC, Canada

Posts: 2,250

, thanks hybrid. Good to get feedback like that, i will try to add even more detail in the future user added image

"I should call you sugar maple tree cause i'd totally tap that" haha

email - mattwettstein@gmail.com

Last edited by M; 12-04-2003 at 04:55 AM.

Quote

# 5 12-04-2003 , 05:20 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003

Location: New York, USA

Posts: 1,945

I agree with hybrid. I voted for M.

JKLaroe's gun seemed very hard to tell.. the actual gun if you understand. seemed very basic and simple. Which isnt a bad thing all the time, simple can have amazing effects sometimes.. but it was too generic. Mybe a little more deffinition woudl help.

M's was well detailed and well designed compared to the original. very nice. The only comments is loking at the wireframe it looked like a lot of cylinders and so where barely edited but it did come out to the finished product excellently. so no complaints.

I think m's was better, more complex and all.. but if laroes gun was more detailed slightly, with a better render and orginization he had a serious chance to pull a come from behind.

________________________
AIM: SublimeDragon33
Catch me if i'm on. Always up for a chat.
e-mail: sublimedragon33@gmail.com

Quote

# 6 12-04-2003 , 06:45 AM

Subscriber
Join Date: Jan 2003

Location: BC, Canada

Posts: 2,250

Thanks twisted user added image

... yea, there were a ton of cylinders! lol. Anyways, you can see my continued progress on the WIP section.. cya user added image

"I should call you sugar maple tree cause i'd totally tap that" haha

email - mattwettstein@gmail.com

Quote

# 7 12-04-2003 , 07:31 AM

Kevin

Guest

Posts: n/a

voted! a great battle both of you... and I think you both learned a lot!!

well done

Quote

# 8 12-04-2003 , 11:44 AM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: with PonysGirl

Posts: 2,573

my vote gose for M if the pole is still going.

just a lot of care went in to tweeking it and asimbaling little parts.

not to mention it was nice detail on the sight, as that was blery in the ref pic and I feel M had to gess..

Quote

# 9 12-04-2003 , 04:45 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Jan 2003

Location: BC, Canada

Posts: 2,250

, thanks pony... yea, haha.. it was terrible as my refrence was a low res, so when i zoomed in to do detail all i had was a blur of colors, lol.

"I should call you sugar maple tree cause i'd totally tap that" haha

email - mattwettstein@gmail.com

Quote

# 10 13-04-2003 , 01:49 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003

Location: New York, USA

Posts: 1,945

thats why you use your imagination user added image

________________________
AIM: SublimeDragon33
Catch me if i'm on. Always up for a chat.
e-mail: sublimedragon33@gmail.com

Quote

# 11 13-04-2003 , 02:43 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2002

Location: Minnesota, USA

Posts: 3,709

Same comment as Kevin user added image

Israel "Izzy" Long
Motion and Title Design for Broadcast-Film-DS
izzylong.com

Quote

# 12 13-04-2003 , 08:39 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Apr 2003

Location: Framingham, MA United States

Posts: 1,112

)v( i think you and i should battle next, although you will win, i will learn much!

"When you are born, you have a resposiblilty to program you're own mind, if you do not accept this responsiblilty, then the world will do it for you"
Aol Instant messenger: mrcoolbp2

Quote

# 13 13-04-2003 , 10:02 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Jan 2003

Location: BC, Canada

Posts: 2,250

LOL, dont say that vectorman! I have seen your realism challenge and you are quite good yourself! We shall see.. i would battle ya next.. first off i want to finish this gun with texturing and all ok? user added image

"I should call you sugar maple tree cause i'd totally tap that" haha

email - mattwettstein@gmail.com

Quote