How to raise surface 'slightly'

# 1 25-05-2004 , 11:38 AM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Hi,
I am trying to learn some basic NURBS modelling techniques by just modelling different objects and trying various ways of making the shape.
At the moment I am attempting to make a "Desk Fan" and am stuck on how to make the "Control Panel' sit slightly proud of the rest of the surface.
Methods tried - I did try to 'offset' the highlighted Isoparm (raised and scaled in very slightly) then Lofted to this curve - But I get very unpredictable results.
The other way I tried was to "Duplicate the surface patches"
then lift them, but then I had problems as I could not seem to Fillet or loft to the edges as everytime I selected the 'duplicated patches' - It would only select 1 patch? (I tried shift/clicking but couldn't get it to work)
Basically my question is, how should I be creating these 'very slightly' raised surfaces.

If you cannot tell from my picture what i'm trying to do, then picture the controls on an IPOD and see how they are slightly proud? that's what I am trying to do.

Regards Scraggy

Attached Images

Quote

# 2 25-05-2004 , 06:08 PM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

Can you post a picture of what you are trying to get? I mean, you say ipod, do have have another example though? Because I'm having trouble understanding.
Why don't you just pick a few CVs and move them up? Or you can create the panel as an entirerly different surface and just have it sit ontop of that surface intersecting (so you can't see holes) but not actually conected.

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 3 25-05-2004 , 09:09 PM

The Maya Mountain
Join Date: Aug 2002

Location: Seattle, WA

Posts: 8,245

I'd imagine you'd want to grab the Hull for the CV row you want to manipulate and move it up.

-Mike
The Maya Toolbelt

Quote

# 4 25-05-2004 , 10:38 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Hope this is a bit better...

Hi,
Thanks, I realised I did not shift selected the 'top' isoparm in the last Pic i sent, so no wonder it was confusing to you...

Sorry about that, I have a picture here but unfortunately it is very blurred due to the "Auto Guess" Focus on my Digi camera.

I hope you can see what i'm trying to do (I wasn't being quite so bold and was content with 1 raised surface, as you can just about - see there are 2 'ridges' on the Fan)

Plus I had no idea how to get the sides flat like that so used 'artistic liscence' If you have any ideas how I should have done it, I would be grateful.

Ow yeah and the Fan blades are next - I was thinking that 'Birail' or just twisting a Nurbs loft would do... But that's theory user added image

Regards Scraggy_d

Last edited by Scraggy_dog; 25-05-2004 at 10:41 PM.

Quote

# 5 25-05-2004 , 10:43 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Picture

Oops.

As you can see now - it's more of an abrupt change than I can get from just manipulating vertices (I think?)

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: fan1pic.jpg
Views: 435
Size: 47.3 KB
ID: 15390

Quote

# 6 26-05-2004 , 06:58 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

Ok, I think what I would do project a curve to that surface from the top view where I want that raised panel to go ("Edit NURBS>Project Curve On Surface" with the default options). Then I would offset that surface a little bit ("Edit NURBS>Offset Surfaces", then chose the options to chose how much to offset it). Then I would select the first surface and click "Edit NURBS>Trim Tool" and click on the part of the surface that I want to show, press enter. Then I would repeat that last step to trim the second surface. Then to create the conection between the 2 surfaces right click the first surface and chose "Trim Edge", then select the edge of the trim in that surface, then while holding shift do the same for the second surface. So now with both edges selected click "Edit NURBS>Surface Fillet>Freeform Fillet". And that's it, there you have your raised panel.
Additionaly, I think I can see a little edge around that panel, I could be wrong, I can't really tell by the picture. Well, in that case then just repeat the same thing by first duplication the original curve twice and making them one smalled than the other.

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 7 26-05-2004 , 11:05 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Hi..

Hi NightPhantom,

Thanks a lot for your explanation, one thing I realised that I had not even tried yet was "Offset Surfaces" ...
I am really glad you showed me that as I'm sure as soon as I get the 'hang' of this... I have 1 problem though -

I have tried to follow along with your explanation, but sadly I seem to get stuck at the part where I connect the two halves together.

I have also realised that an edge of a Nurbs is not necessarrily an Isoparm (Because I cannot select it to 'Fillet' to.) - So I did "Surface point"/"drag"/"Create Isoparm" -But it is all skewed wrongly.....[See on last photo]

I may just start again knowing more now.
I'm thinking, if my Isoparm isn't as mis-aligned, then maybe the fillet will work?

Regards Scraggy

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: nurbspanel.jpg
Views: 445
Size: 54.6 KB
ID: 15409

Quote

# 8 27-05-2004 , 12:15 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

I'll post a more detailed explanation, but this will take a while (I want to take snapshots and the whole deal), so bear with me. It shouldn't take more than 20 minutes though...

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 9 27-05-2004 , 12:33 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2004

Location: UK

Posts: 352

While nightphantom is writhing his essay (which will be very good coz he helped me out a while back). You could try using the subtract booleans tool using a nurbs cylinder to give the desired cutout.

Quote

# 10 27-05-2004 , 01:33 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

Dammit!

I was in the middle of taking screenshots of the intructions when something got messed up in one of the surfaces and I can't find a way to fix is (it's a bug). Some how the normals of the surface apear outside the surface, I thought it was a problem with my video card, but it stays there no matter what I do (not even undo worked). Ans since I'm too lazy to do it al over again, I'll just "type" the detailed instructions intead. Sorry. user added image

Well, here we go.

1.- create you surface, I will refer to this as "surface 1", but you can call it whatever you want.

2.- select surface one and then click "Edit NURBS>Offset Surfaces".

3.- open the attribute edito and it should be displaying the option for the offset that you just did. I will refer to the new surface as "surface 2".

4.- in the attribute editor, under "Offset Surface History" change the "distance" value as you see fit. For me it worked fine with 0.3. The number will be negative or positive depending on where the surface normals are pointing at.

5.- before you continue make sure both surfaces are closed, specially because surface 2 might have a gap somewhere because of the way the surface is offset.

6.- go to the top view and draw a closed curve where you want the surface to be raised.

7.- while still in the top view, select that curve and both surface 1 and surface 2 and then click "Edit NURBS>Project Curve on Surface".

8.- select surface 2 and then click "Edit NURBS>Trim Tool".

9.- the surface will aprea as a white grid now, where the curve that you projected to it will be thicker than the rest, and the area above the curve will have a different looking grid than the area below the curve (this lets you know that the curve is actually separating the surface in two parts).

10.- the way the trim tool works is, you mark with a yellow cube the part of the surface that you want to keep and you do nothing to the part that you want to get rid of. So click somewhere in the top part of the surface (by the way, we are working in persp view now).

11.- hit enter. Now part of the surface should be gone. Make sure you kept the part that you wanted to keep before you continue. If you got the wrong one just click "Edit NURBS>Untrim Surfaces".

12.- repeat steps 8, 9, 10, and 11, except that this time select surface 1, and leave the yellow square on the oposite part of the surface.

13.- now you should have something that looks like the image that I did posted in this post (look bellow this text); except for that yellow edge, I'll explain the yellow in a moment.

14.- if you have trimed the surfaces where they should be trimed and nos have two halves of the surface offset from one another, then it's time to select the trim edge.

15.- hold down the right mouse button over surface 1 until a little menu pops up. From the menu chose "Trim Edge". Now carefully click where the yellow line that I mentioned in step 13 is. So not yours should look like the picture.

16.- repeat step 15 with surface 2, but before you click the edge remmember to hold down "Shift" so that you don't lose the previous selection.

17.- if you have the 2 yellow lines, click "Edit NURBS>Surface Fillet>Freeform Fillet".

18.- with some luck, that did it, and it's the end of it, congratulations. However, you might get a weird twisted surface 3. If that happens then undo the last step (or delete surface 3) and try to change the direcion of the surfaces and try the freeform fillet again. This might take some ingenuity. For example, while attaching the sleves in my parrot pirate for this month's challenge I got the twisted fillet, it after poking arround a bit I realized that the surface for the sleve (which started as a cylinder) had it's begining CV pointing north, while the curve that I projected to the chest had it's first CV pointing south. I solved the problem by simply rotating the curve to match up the sleeve. Deleting history also helps some times.

Good luck with that. And sorry I couldn't get the screen shots like I said I would user added image

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: trim result.jpg
Views: 412
Size: 52.0 KB
ID: 15410

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 11 27-05-2004 , 02:40 AM

Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2004

Location: UK

Posts: 352

Crap sorry misread what you were trying to do. Damn good explanation NightPhantom!

Quote

# 12 27-05-2004 , 05:47 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Many thanks.......

Thank you very much for taking the time out to explain that to me in detail. I have now learned .......

(a) How to use the "Offset surface" tool (Although I could not find the attribute for distance in the editor [I'm on Maya 4.5] but that's no matter while I have Undo
(b) How to select curves using "Trim edge" (I had never even noticed that one before!)

I must admit when I started the trim and realised that I needed to select "TWO" surfaces to keep, I fluttered a bit until I realised that you can shift-select a second surface to keep. user added image

I have followed your little 'tutorial' on a copied fan so I could play with the settings e.t.c. and am happy to say it came out like this..... (See below) on the first try...

Ok next - (So I can learn more NURBS) I am going to try to make a "Fan Propellor" next.
- I think I will try to use Birail tools to create it as they look very powerful tools to know, and at the time of writing, I haven't a clue as to how to use them.

Thanks again guys Scraggy

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: filletworks.jpg
Views: 430
Size: 9.4 KB
ID: 15411

Quote

# 13 27-05-2004 , 06:38 PM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

I am using Maya 4.5 too, and the "distance" attribute is in the picture below. You have to make sure the new surface is the one selected (which will happen as soon as you offset it, so just don't click anything else until you get to play with the distance attribute). I like using that from the attribute editor instead of the tool options because that way I get to see what I'm getting in real time.

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: offset distance.jpg
Views: 396
Size: 95.2 KB
ID: 15421

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 14 27-05-2004 , 06:43 PM

Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003

Location: Florida

Posts: 269

Also, in the original photograph that you posted I see that the base conects to the rest of the fan smoothly (not an an angle). You can achieve that look with surface fillets too. Try projecting a straight line against that column from the side or front view; then select the bottom most isoparm in the colum and go tot he curves menu and chose the first option (duplicate surface curve or soemthing like that). That gives you a second curve independent of the surface, resize it to make it a bit bigger than the base and then project (from the top view) to the base, then trim it, then trim the bottom of the column, and do a freeform fillet between the two edges.

There can not be Good without Evil, so then it must be good to be Evil sometimes.

:tup:

Quote

# 15 27-05-2004 , 09:18 PM

Subscriber
Join Date: Mar 2003

Location: Manchester UK

Posts: 159

Hiya,
Thanks for that, user added image

At first you mention Surface fillets, then at the end it says to do a "freeform fillet" - I am wondering now what the differences are.?
[Maybe not easy to explain?]

I Tried to do what you said about the base but got rather confused in the process. (Pic enclosed)
I am a slow learner it seems, (Can't teach an old dogg new tricks?) but I will go onto the Alias site and look up all the fillets and especially "Duplicate surface Curve" on 3D-101 ....
- I will have a mess around with it - then if I still cannot get the "hang" of it - I will come and Bug y'all again user added image