I would assume that you don't have shadows turned on.
If a light doesn't cast shadows then it doesn't know which parts of the mode are in shadow and which are illuminated. So it illuminates everything.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1b8f/f1b8f14fa566a36214fc41c7c19e0bcb7d875477" alt="Ninja user added image"
A
PS. Please don't double post.
Technical Director - Framestore
Currently working on: Your Highness
IMDB